Clarkesworld #242, November 2026

Clarkesworld #242, November 2026

“Twenty-Two Steps to Become Us” by Hannah Yang

“The Meat Market” by Isabel J. Kim

“The Exchange Service” by R.T. Ester

“Trimmed From The Night” by Raahem Alvi

“Black Ice Burning” by Rati Mehrotra

“Then Is the Ghosts’ High Noon” by Eric Del Carlo

“Twenty-Nine Days Before Remaking the World” by Mimi Mondal

Reviewed by Tim Nall

In “Twenty-Two Steps to Become Us” by Hannah Yang, Jolene, a recently divorced history professor, has moved back into her childhood bedroom in Seattle, where her widowed mother spends her days with a dozen Learners, humanoid copies that grow more like their trainers the longer they follow them around. Jolene has always refused to train one, but her department now requires it, so she starts on the twenty-two-step training module. As her Learner grows her face and voice, her mother seems to prefer the copy to the daughter, and the story moves toward a quarrel that leaves something irreplaceable in pieces on the floor.

The craft is impressive. It’s often wise to build a story like a sandwich: plot, character development, rising tension and emotional arc should sit together so that each bite has a taste of everything. Yang works personal details, relationship history and feeling into nearly every scene. The best example is the pork belly with Shaoxing wine her father taught her to cook. The Learner masters it along with her handwriting and her laptop, so a step in the machine’s training is freighted with a cherished memory of him. And then, of course, there is the vase.

Baba, Jolene’s late father and a ceramicist, gets far less time on the page than Mama, yet I suspect he gets more of Jolene’s love. In an old home video he promises to pass down the old ways, and the young Jolene answers, “I’ll learn to be like the old masters, Baba.” Her Learner has already copied her face and voice, but when it mouths that promise back at her, Jolene shuts the video off. That memory, at least, she won’t let a copy take. This is the moment the story touches her essence, though it doesn’t linger there. The vase he is painting in that video, invested with her memories of him, is the one that will later shatter.

The story’s two-sided view of the Learners runs through its memories of Baba. Early on, Jolene thinks that if he were still here, he “would have hated seeing me with a Learner,” as “a mockery of the art he made with his own hands.” Yet Mama remembers him differently. When a customer laughed that she could buy the same vase cheaper at Home Goods, Baba said, “It’s good that more people can have beautiful things in their homes.” His generosity grants that copies can be valuable, even to a craftsman.

Its turning point, for me, comes in the grocery store, where Jolene stops passively resenting and starts seeking what is real, testing a friendly stranger in the checkout line with deliberate nonsense until his face slips and shows him to be a Learner. After that, she names her true grievance: Mama spends more time with the Learner than with her own daughter. Jolene’s experiences show that the convenience copies offer does not extend to letting one stand in for a person, and that is where the story puts the real harm.

The ending is the story’s best feature, and its strength comes from being less. Quiet endings are hardly new; Raymond Carver’s “A Small, Good Thing” closes with grieving parents sharing bread with a baker. What feels distinctive here is how the love is shown. The copy murmurs endless apologies; mother and daughter offer none, and neither says “I love you.” Mama brings rubber gloves and kneels to help despite her bad back, and that is all the declaration this family needs. After so much about how humanity is being lost, the story recovers it without a fight, in a few quiet minutes on a bedroom floor.

There is a Daoist term for this, ziran, literally “self-so,” the way things are of themselves when nothing artificial interferes. The Dao De Jing says the Dao itself follows ziran. Here, no one argues anyone into reconciling, and no one explicitly draws a lesson. Mama ushers Jolene Two out of the room and comes back alone to help. Their closeness returns without either of them forcing it.

The story resists by not resisting. The Learners threaten our human identity, and the scene with the shards answers that threat without wholly opposing them. Nothing, for example, suggests that Jolene Two will not go to work. Minutes earlier, Mama has said that everything a person must do these days is too much to do alone. Now, when Jolene tells her to let a Learner do the work, she says no: “I want to do this with you.” The story redefines what it means to be a person, from a list of tasks and efficient output to something shared.

Jolene’s own change is a restoration. She learns to trust a center she knew was there all along. Through most of the story she believes she is right and everyone around her is wrong, yet she is unsettled; what she doubts is whether her view matters at all. On the floor with the shards she trusts that her view is right, even before she can say exactly what it is, because it is in harmony with how things truly are. Chinese has a four-character idiom (chengyu) for this state, 心安理得 (xīn ān lǐ dé): the heart at peace because it accords with lǐ, the natural pattern of things. Nothing has to be won. Right is right, and knowing that is enough to bring her to rest.

If the story has a weakness, it is that the middle could have been richer. The stakes are clear, with plenty of damage, but much of it arrives as commentary on the economics of the Learners. What’s thin is Jolene. Mama is vivid from the first page, while Jolene becomes an observer of her world and goes quiet at her deepest moment. When her Learner parrots that childhood promise, she switches off the TV and leaves for the store, and we never learn what it costs her to watch her father alive. The kneeling at the end would hit harder if we had lived more inside the woman who kneels.

This story will appeal to readers who like quiet, family-centered science fiction about what automation might take from ordinary life. It is strongly recommended.

In “The Meat Market” by Isabel J. Kim, the unnamed narrator lives in a nest of six curved screens and energy-drink cans and runs a swarm of cobbled-together AI agents. He makes his living on 100% MATCHED, a dating app with a built-in prediction market. Its users are either “singles,” who use the app to date, or “cupids,” who never date on it and instead bet on the singles: who will match with whom, when they will meet and how soon they will break up. His bets keep going wrong, and he becomes convinced that one person is planting irresistible fake profiles to wreck them. Eventually his agents uncover her name and the bar where she drinks at Wednesday happy hour. He goes there, tentatively planning to confront her and then report her to the SEC.

Much of the story’s color comes from the narrator’s lifestyle and his bragging. The details are the ones a very online reader in their twenties or early thirties would recognize from their own lives: White Monster, a Minecraft window kept open for downtime, a narrator who tells his imagined chat that he’s “cooked,” wojaks, mogging, anime figurines on a shelf, driving rideshare when funds run low. For that reader, the humor works by recognition: I know this guy, I might be this guy. For a reader outside that culture (such as me), the same details don’t work as recognition; they read as noise. Worse, they read as the narrator trying too hard to catch attention. Even allowing for that, the details repeat more than they develop. The White Monster cans come back three times by name, he calls his chair and screens his cradle four times, and he tells himself again and again to lock in, but each return adds nothing new about him.

The story’s larger problems go beyond generational taste. The most serious is that it drops its own biggest revelation. Well into the story, Nancy shows him that about two-thirds of the app’s users are fakes made by the company itself, which ought to upend everything for a man who bets on those users and prides himself on knowing things. This rattles him briefly, but it hardly changes his strategy, and beyond a passing remark or two the story does nothing with it. The stakes evaporate in the same way. When Nancy vanishes with both of his computers and wipes the agents he spent weeks training, the loss should cripple a man whose income depends on them, yet within a couple of weeks he has built a new machine and is betting again.

What remains is a familiar story of a lonely man who meets a woman, falls for her quickly and loses her, but even that heartbreak has little built behind it, because the courtship goes by in summary: drinks, a dinner, a movie and a hookup in the back of his car. The narrator’s one real change also happens offstage. At some point he stops meaning to report Nancy, but the story mentions it only afterward, in passing, and every decisive act in the climax is hers.

The closing paragraph is the most affecting moment in the story, since what he has left of her is what he knows of her voice, her eyes and her chatlogs; it comes, however, too late and too briefly to give the ending much heft.

This story will appeal to younger, very online readers who recognize the narrator’s world from their own feeds, enjoy satire of AI-saturated dating culture, and love a story of lost love.

On my first read, I had no idea what the heck was going on in “The Exchange Service” by R.T. Ester. For example, I spent the first 1,500 words thinking that the main characters are aliens, before the story finally identifies them as human (and does so in the middle of a sentence about an alien’s secretion). So I read the whole thing again. Slowly. Even then, much of the story stays murky. Turns out, there are three kinds of unreality in the story: one sleeping dream, several waking visions, and, for some reason, a hummingbird memory (in the ending, which I try to unravel below) that is “not awake and not sleeping.” The narration presents all three in the same flat, unmarked way as the waking scenes. That’s the core of why it was difficult to tell what was going on, since readers are given little or no signal of which kind of scene they’re in until afterward, if ever. Plus, key facts are scattered and buried throughout. So in the following story summary, I had to piece together many details. And guess at a few others.

The protagonist (Meka) is a “channel,” one of a hundred humans kept in stasis on a station and woken when one of the Merge, beings who live for thousands of years, comes to visit. In a pool, the channels fall asleep humming and merge into a group mind called a chorus; only about a third of the way in, through the station’s recaps, did I work out that the chorus and the alien are negotiating in chord progressions. A few people, the “listeners,” can hear the Merge directly, and the gift ages them quickly. This visitor, called starseer, wants vengeance for the destruction of its worlds. Meka is extremely attached to Kira (Meka’s bandmate? lover? sister? daughter? I lean, tentatively, toward the last), a listener who has long been missing, whom he followed into the service and has been looking for ever since she disappeared. With the help of Odion, a fellow channel he meets at the story’s outset, he slowly comes to accept that the Kira he keeps glimpsing around the station may not really be there.

The ideas are the most promising thing here. The story’s chorus, a hundred sleepers humming together in the presence of an alien, is a fresh picture of first contact, and the claim that remembering the Merge’s history is what ages a listener gives the premise a price. As I said, however, the overall incomprehensibility is the main problem. The middle also sags, with long conversations in which Meka keeps laughing at himself without moving the story forward. And the prose is uneven: vivid moments, such as starseer’s pores, each as large as a stasis pod, sit beside odd word choices, and stares and grins that recur until they stop registering.

I think the story starts in the wrong place. It opens on procedure: steam, towels, ninety-nine glistening bodies in a staging room and a rush of invented terms, with Kira mentioned only in passing. A better opening sits a few paragraphs later, in medias res: “She told him her name was Odion. While they stood and submitted to physicals administered by the station’s appendages, she described a dream she had while she woke from stasis. It was pleasant.” That intriguingly flat verdict is followed at once by “In stasis, he never dreamed,” and by Meka’s numbing body and the sound of Kira’s laughter as he drifts off. Those few lines do what the current opening doesn’t: they make Kira the first thing Meka feels, and they establish dreams as the story’s terrain, so readers would at least be watching for the dreams and visions that later prove so confusing. Some of the actual opening is still worth keeping: a trimmed version, with the image of the bodies in the steam and enough grounding for terms such as the station’s appendages and hearing the Merge, could follow just after it.

And what exactly is the story trying to say? I’m not sure, but I’ll take a wild-eyed guess. Starseer’s grief over its ruined worlds seems meant to mirror Meka’s over Kira, though it reaches readers only indirectly, so the parallel stays a notion rather than a feeling. About a third of the way in, a passage from an old scripture is found defacing Meka’s shower stall: “Now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known.” Nothing tells the reader where it comes from (1 Corinthians 13:12), and the story sets it down without quotation marks, without any reaction from Meka, and without the crucial first half of the verse, about seeing “through a glass, darkly; but then face to face.” My guess is that this verse is the key to the ending, and that the story is really about the longing to be truly seen, but it leaves readers to make that connection entirely on their own.

Difficult prose can leave readers unable to say what they’ve read, but prose that’s too easy gives them nothing to chew on. Good writing balances the two: it challenges readers while still guiding them, so the depth is worth the effort and the meaning stays clear. “The Exchange Service” clearly falls on the first side. It asks for deep engagement but gives too little guidance, so readers do the work without being sure of what they found. This story may appeal to patient readers of strange first-contact fiction built on grief and memory who are willing to sort the dreams, visions and waking scenes out for themselves.

“Trimmed From The Night” by Raahem Alvi is wall-to-wall bodies and graphic gore from the first page, which offers a dislocated jaw “hanging by threads of sinew,” a brain coating the ground, and Afrah “shoveling neurons and fascia between her fingers.” Most stories build up to that level, if they reach it at all. This one opens there and stays for several paragraphs.

Afrah, a twenty-eight-year-old corpse collector, and Kamran, the old veteran who flies their ship, travel through an interstellar war recovering bodies someone has paid to bring home. Their ship, the Lunar-Maria 01, is an old delivery vessel refitted as a morgue, with a freezer strapped to its back. The corporate powers waging the war don’t live on the planets where it is fought, so orbital bombardment and massacre are routine, and the pair spend much of their working day dodging railgun fire while they scrape soldiers off the ground. Years of handling remains have convinced Afrah that people are only meat, and that includes her boyfriend, DD, whose loving messages she can barely bring herself to answer. A job to retrieve the head of a warship’s commander, which carries valuable company data in a brain implant, goes badly wrong, and the two end up stranded on Nos, a planet destroyed by nuclear strikes when Kamran was an eighteen-year-old soldier, where it turns out he has unfinished business.

The main weakness is that the theme is stated again and again. Afrah’s belief that consciousness is only a survival tool of the body is explained in narration and then argued aloud (“The real pilot has always been the meat.”), and Kamran answers with speeches about which bodies the powerful bother to count. The ideas might be interesting, but by the midpoint readers have heard them several times, and the narration keeps adding short general pronouncements about death and grief that do the reader’s thinking in advance. Afrah’s feelings are often named in scenes whose action already conveys them, and her fear of abandonment is spelled out in a single passage of summary.

The story’s chief strength is Kamran, its most fully realized person: gruff, protective and funny in a gallows way, a would-be famous tennis player who ended up a corpse collector. His odd habit of smacking the side of his head pays off late, when a flashback shows that Millie’s dying screams are still lodged in his head, and the scene where he feeds the injured Afrah by hand is the story’s warmest moment. The next best material is in the individual retrievals, most of which get a section named for the dead person, so that the bodies pile up across the story much as they do in Afrah’s freezer.

The gore is explicit throughout, with wet cracking bones, fluids leaking from pores and rotting tissue described in close detail. In the story’s defense, most of it shows the aftermath of violence, there is no torture, and except for Millie’s death by fire the story rarely lingers on suffering; all of it serves the argument about meat. A seasoned reader of grimdark or horror might call it heavy but purposeful. Still, there is so much of it that the repetition dulls its force, and some readers will give up by the second page, or even somewhere on the first.

Afrah is also moved by the plot more often than she moves it. Kamran drags her away from a begging soldier, hauls her back aboard during an escape, and later carries her and hides her. His last stand takes place offstage, heard through a door, which gives away what could have been the story’s strongest scene. And unless I missed a reason for it, the accident that strands the pair on Nos, of all the planets in the war, felt like a convenience.

The ending is stronger. A phone call between Afrah and DD near the close is the emotional peak, and it works because his short, hopeful text messages have kept their relationship alive all along. The final section, told from DD’s point of view, leans toward overstatement in places, but its picture of grief is specific and painful, and it is where the title’s image finally appears.

Alvi’s prose is vivid and often striking, though uneven. This story will appeal to readers with a strong stomach for gore who like war SF told from the point of view of the people who clean up after the fighting.

“Black Ice Burning” by Rati Mehrotra is narrated from inside a sentient house in Toronto in 2055, nearly twenty years into its hiding from a post-pandemic world. Depressed, the house rents itself out over the protests of its freed robots, Simi and Hector. The tenant is Pelican, an ailing former writer on Simi’s favorite television space opera, who now and then blinks out of existence. The house recognizes the symptom, because the same disease turned its former owner, David, into a monster who killed his family, and it has kept him locked in the basement ever since. The story builds to the evening the door gives way.

Telling a haunted-house story from the house’s side is a good idea, but the climax belongs to someone else. When the monster breaks out, the house freezes and then readies a self-destruct; before it can act, Pelican vanishes with the creature and comes back alone. The rule that makes this work, that whatever she touches goes with her, is explained only afterward, and the house admits it was saved “through no effort of mine.” Its regret over two decades of hiding goes nowhere, and a few pages later it goes to sleep.

Nothing is hard won, either. The house gets the company it wanted almost as soon as it advertises. Simi’s torn-off arms go back into their sockets within minutes, and the house’s darkest history (an incinerator, and thirty-eight bodies in the garden) is raised and dropped. After a real build, the ending offers a round of explanations and a press release celebrating Simi’s fan fiction.

Apart from the house, the cast stays at the level of comic types. A family’s murder, meanwhile, is told in the same breezy register as the house’s beauty-pageant avatar and Simi’s erotic fan fiction, so to me the horror read as played for laughs. Long stretches of the middle go to trivia about the show while the creature waits offstage, and when D-305 does appear, it gloats and offers its victim a poem.

Much of the prose is lightweight, leaning on stock idioms with a machine word swapped in, jokes that stop to explain themselves, feelings named rather than shown (the house diagnoses itself with ennui), and moods announced by a robot changing color.

This story will appeal mainly to readers who enjoy chatty AI narrators and fandom humor, and who don’t mind a monster dispatched by someone other than the hero.

In “Then Is the Ghosts’ High Noon,” Eric Del Carlo sends sixteen-year-old Cavan Keely and three other juvenile offenders to the Docks to serve three months scraping alien growths off military supply boats under a slovenly, bullying overseer named Oberst. The growths, stinking gray nodes the size of an infant’s head, collect on ships that fly through the skies of an enemy nobody can talk to. As Cavan toughens up and grows close to his crewmates, an older girl named Ivy asks whether he has ever tried listening to the nodes, and later asks him to bring her one, whole.

From its first sentence, which announces that the crew’s tags “told almost the entire tale,” the story tells itself as a summary. The opening sums up the sentence, the port and the overseer, whom the narrator dismisses as a Dickensian cliché; most of the introductions and three of the four confessions are summarized; the first shift is explained as instructions, then skipped to its end; and the port’s color and the diner’s loud talk are described again and again. Nearly a third of the story passes before a scene plays out in dialogue, when Ivy appears behind Cavan on a quiet walk.

The events the plot turns on suffer most. Readers never see Cavan decide to steal a node; the activists’ voyage to the aliens and their arrest take a few sentences of report; and the reason for his own crime, that his mother was drafted and died in combat, is mentioned in passing near the end, so for most of the story his help for Ivy reads as a crush rather than a conviction. The stakes stay small, too: the only price paid on the page, three more months for all four, is shrugged off in a line, and by the story’s own account the activists’ gesture has no visible effect on the war.

Del Carlo’s best writing is in side details, such as Ivy flicking Cavan’s tag so it spins on its invisible lanyard, though they sit among stock cues like a roiling stomach. The liveliest passage comes when a drunk with a glowing prosthetic eye grabs Cavan’s shirt and demands his views on the war, sending him back to the acid he used on his hab’s war memorial, the bronze bubbling and the plaque to the fallen melting away; it is the clearest view of his anger. The late suggestion that the nodes may be the aliens’ dead, laid perhaps in graveyards high in the sky, gives the drudgery a sad weight, and the four teenagers setting each node down with a prayer was a nice touch. Yet the prayer is perhaps the sharpest example of the story’s habit of summary: its words are never given, so the final emotional beat is summed up instead of shown, when even a single line would have let readers hear what Cavan has come to believe about the nodes and the war and given the ending the moment the story keeps skipping. Cavan, too, listens to the nodes only once, and the idea shapes almost nothing before the narration hedges it with a run of maybes.

Most of the cast stays thin. Azora and Timothy are little more than names and crimes, Ivy seems to exist mainly to recruit Cavan, and a glimpse of a refined Oberst behind the act goes nowhere. Bethany fares best: her shamefaced admission that her assault on a recruiter amounted to throwing a frozen dessert is the most unguarded moment in the story, though it, too, arrives as report.

This story will appeal to readers who like a strange, strong speculative image and a quiet, reverent ending, and who are willing to extend ample forgiveness to the sketchy and mostly forgettable telling around it.

In “Twenty-Nine Days Before Remaking the World,” Mimi Mondal follows Salt, a twenty-one-year-old street thief whose town, Rachtown, has been razed by a giant wave, as she walks east with other refugees toward Nastre, the rich Moonlands nation whose people pray to the moon Lustra as the gaze of God. For better resettlement terms she has married, on paper, Rainfall, a gentle, sheltered rich man. At the border Salt collapses with code fever, the hallucinations that seize anyone who etches a stolen sacred code onto their skin, a crime Nastre punishes with death; as a child she inked one under her foot. The voice in her head is Samina, the face of something like an ancient machine buried in the moon by an earlier humanity, and what Samina tells her sets her against the quiet life Rainfall hopes for.

Salt is Mondal’s best asset: her wryness gives the early pages bite, the fit at moonrise is vivid and frightening, and the childhood etching worn away under barefoot calluses is an image only this story could have, though her voice fades once Samina fills her head. Rainfall is tender but almost too good to be real, with an untested condescending edge (he answers her revelations as if she were a child). Salt’s feelings for him are often stated outright, and the romance leaves its richest feeling untouched: the two avoid asking why the other is alone, so their losses in the wave barely surface.

Nearly everything happens to Salt. The fever, the languages, the history and the mission are all gifts from Samina, and the danger never presses: no guard suspects her, Samina’s doom would unfold over a thousand years, and the Inviolate Priests who hold Nastre’s power never appear, leaving Rainfall’s piety as the only opposition on the page. Two setups, Salt’s etched childhood friend Soup and the refugees who vanish from the camps, go unused. A god who is a machine is familiar ground; Mondal’s fresher move is to make the machine the moral agent. As I read it, the story argues that hoarded knowledge becomes power dressed as divine favor, and that history repeats: the old humanity abandoned its poorest, and Nastre’s priests built a religion that keeps half the world deprived. Samina, enraged at having served it, means to withdraw from the world, turning the robot uprising on its head. Packing a lost humanity, a church, a romance and a mission into about 4,200 words, the story summarizes the wrong thing, narrating on the twenty-ninth day the turn that decides the ending, so the story’s most original idea gets its thinnest treatment. Salt begins to tell Rainfall, the scene dissolves (“She didn’t know where to start”), and she slips away while he sleeps; the one confrontation the story builds never reaches the page.

The departure, a hero leaving a sleeping lover to answer a call, is a stock scene with two personal touches: Salt, half fearing she is mad, goes partly to spare Rainfall her execution, and she takes the dream of a marble-floored house with her instead of renouncing it. The closing sentence restates that hope in stock legend phrasing and misses the story’s best image, the callused foot that hides the etching that began everything; a last step on that foot would have tied the ending to this story alone. What Salt means to do at Nastre Bowl, the holy city at the center of the world, is left unsaid, as far as I can tell; the story ends on an intention and reads like the opening chapter of a saga.

Still, the story’s faults should not obscure what it does well. Although Salt is mainly passive, she does make one real choice, and her quips and calluses make her vivid enough that readers want to see her win, which gives her surrender of the life in the hills some cost. The farewell, although a familiar trope, is the story’s best moment, as she kisses Rainfall while he sleeps, breathes him in one last time, and goes on holding to hope though the world may be doomed. Perhaps, too, if read generously, the departure is more of a climax than it first seems, since both sides of her choice are on the page, Rainfall and the quiet life on one, a world its god means to abandon on the other, and the story lets her register what she gives up before she goes.

This story will appeal to readers who enjoy bittersweet romances set against secret histories, and who approve of an ending that is really a beginning. Recommended.